Our artisan bakers skillfully craft each pie with fresh seasonal ingredients and our signature all butter pastry.

We offer a variety of 5" mini pies each day at the Studio, and a very limited number of 10" signature flavor pies. We have the following signature flavors daily, year round: Chocolate Chess; Lemon Chess; Maple Pecan; Chocolate Bourbon Pecan; Dutch Apple. We then offer a changing selection of fruit pies, creams and custards. Our daily menu is driven by seasonal ingredients, custom orders, and the creativity of our bakers. Please check our Facebook page for our daily menu to see what we are baking.  

All custom pies must be ordered 48 hours in advance. This ensures the pie you Crave will be served to you freshly baked and delicious.  

If you don’t see a flavor you Crave, let us know and we can come up with something special just for you. 

We are now baking with apples, berries, tart cherries, and citrus. 

Cream, Custard, and Chess Pie Flavors

Banana Cream


Butterscotch Cream

Chocolate Banana Cream, Chocolate Chess, Chocolate Cream

Coconut Cream, Coconut Custard


Key Lime

Lemon Chess, Raspberry Lemon Chess, Lemon Icebox, Lemon Meringue

Ode to Boston Cream


Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Cream or Peanut Butter Fudge

Pumpkin (fresh roasted in season)

Strawberry Cream (fresh berries in season)

Sugar Cream (aka Hoosier Cream)

Sweet Potato (fall and winter)
Classic or Praline

Seasonal Fruit Pies

Classic Apple,  Dutch Apple (Year Round)

Blueberry, Strawberry (Late Spring-Summer)

Classic Cherry,  Cherry Crumb (Jan-Oct)

Classic Peach, Peach Crumb (July-August)

Pear (Fall/Winter)

Pineapple (Year Round)

Rhubarb (April-June)


Can’t find what you’re looking for? Email us at orders@cravepie.com to discuss custom order options.